Replacing the Tivo
Bookmark :
I loved my Tivo. However, after seven years chugging away under the TV, I decided I not only wanted a PVR (personal video recorder - of which Tivo is an excellent example), but also a decent DVD player, and a decent media server, allowing me to play movies of a file server. All in HD of course (as soon as I get the wife to agree to a new TV, of course). So, here in Yurope, Tivo only sold version 1 players (so no networking - officially - though 9th Tee did an ethernet card) - which of course dont do HD..
Friends tried to get a windows media player to work, but their marriage only just survived. So I'm not putting any shonky MS software below my TV, thank you very much. If you have that solution working - your a better person than I.
So what could I do. A Mac Mini seemed the right route. Small, practically silent, and has a DVI output (and DVI->RGB and DVI-DH leads). So far so good. What about recording TV ? Digital TV ? Well, a wee device for 70 euros - a TubeStick - seemed to do that well. And what about providing a nice easy-to-use user interface ? Media Central - by the same folks as the Tubestick - seemed to get decent reviews.
A brief eBay frenzy (Mac Mini for £360 - including a copy of iWorks) and a DVI->RGB cable from Apple for £15, a new S-Video cable and a half-an-hour rummaging in the huge boxes of 'spares' in my barn, and we were in business. I even rescued an external USB 500gb hard drive which wasnt really being used. So its now landed below the TV, and doing sterling work as a media server. The Tubestick TV stuff is pretty good (a couple of seconds of lost lip-sync at the start), picture quality is excellent. Its still not replaced the frankly confusing Humax Digital TV recorder. A matter of time, and tweaking software, methinks.
One of the pleasing side-effects of having a Mac below the TV is that the Mac remote-control software allows us to take over the machine from any one of the three Macbooks (or Pro's) that litter my living room, so we dont have to use a bluetooth keyboard or mouse (yet - its coming). Another pleasing side effect is that since we missed Dr Who on Saturday, we could just fire up Safari on the Mac Mini, and use the excellent BBC iPlayer service to watch it again - streaming live onto the TV. SWMBO of course wanted to see how to do this, and since the remote control is built right into Finder, an absolute doddle to use.
Lessons learnt:
- Dont tell the missus whats going on till its all working...
- The resolution out of a normal tube-based TV (in this case, a 15-year old top-of-the-line Sony) is frankly shocking. Okay for movies and TV, not good for actual computer use. Get a nice new plasma/LCD panel, and run proper HDMI leads to it. Run the color calibration from a normal viewing position - trying to do it with your face pressed against the screen (USB keyboard) wasnt good.
- The Mac Mini is a dual processor 1.8ghz Celeron processor. So it's fine doing streaming or surfing. Just dont try and do anything else at the same time. It only ships with a 40gig or 80gig hard drive - so get yourself a small, silent exernal hard drive to go along with it. I also have it running time-machine backups to this drive, and have shared the drive so we can all just connect to it and watch stuff on the laptops. Which is nice. And now reduces the reliance on the windows 2003 server in the house to Zero. I suspect *that* will be a Linux box real soon now..








Comments
Thanks Bill
I am now running my 2nd Windows Mediacenter in 4 years. The new one I've build about 6 months ago has a Vista reliability index of 10 at the moment and 8+ on average.
I know your sentiments on MS and the Apple solution is a nice one as well ..
Posted by Peter de Haas At 09:32:13 On 26/05/2008 | - Website - |
Did it survive the automatic installation of SP1, as many Vista's didnt ? And how does the PVR perform given that Vista is stealing 60% or more of the CPU?
Its good of you to soldier on with Vista, as I'm sure you have to. But when MS pulls forward Windows next whatever three years to make up for Vista's lack of success in the market, even you have to concede that Vista is just a complete bag of crap.
Unlike Windows ME, *some* people seem happy with it. But not as many as were happy with XP. Hell, even I was a beta tester on XP, and ran it happily for months before gold.
Vista ? Two months of unreliable hell was enough for me. I got a Mac. Well, four now. Loving it too. Its not often, after 22 years in IT, that I actually look forward to using a computer. I do with the Macs.
All the customers I speak to have held off Vista implementations indefinitely, not wishing to have to replace their entire PC desktop installation. I'm sure some suicide jockeys will be pursuded to jump, no doubt given Vista for free to encourage them. And I look forward to the horror stories that will closely follow them.
---* Bill
Posted by Wild Bill At 09:57:57 On 27/05/2008 | - Website - |
This was not intended as a Vista promo
No matter what I personally think of Vista and for whatever reason, the mediacenter is in the *livingroom* doing all kinds of "mission crytical" stuff like
- recording soaps
- Playing our music
- showing our pictures
I guess spouses around the world are the same and not interested in technology at all ...
Regardless of marketshare, enterprise deployments, perceptions, etc, it just works and does one hell of a job.
I purchased my Macbook Air a few months ago by the way
Posted by Peter de Haas At 10:09:38 On 27/05/2008 | - Website - |
Its annoying that this PVR technology has taken so long to get mainstream. Here in Europe, the Tivo series 1 has been quite happily doing this crap for the last eight years.
Its very loyal of you trusting a windows machine with your domestic bliss. Just get a damn good backup on it, so you dont lose your photos..
A macbook Air. Cool. Please god, dont tell me you desecrated that beautiful thing by sticking Vista on it ?
---* Bill
Posted by Wild Bill At 19:43:59 On 28/05/2008 | - Website - |
I have to say I like running MAC OS. The majority of my ' corporate stuff' works natively such as corprate IM (Connecting to OCS2007), email (Entourage to Exchange)and Office for MAC.
What I use most often is Remote Desktop, which actually is very cool ...
As for the backup, I run a Windows HomeServer which backs up all the machines in the house. I even backup the homeserver "in the cloud' using KeepVault.
Posted by Peter de Haas At 20:41:29 On 30/05/2008 | - Website - |